Metal vs. Asphalt Roofing: Which One Is Right for Your Property?

Are you considering changing your residential roof but are torn between metal and asphalt roofing options? Don’t fret because we’re here to help.

Your home’s roof is vital in protecting your property from harmful weather events, excess heat, UV radiation, and fire. Thanks to technological advancements, you can now invest in more durable, recyclable, and energy-efficient roofing products to make your home stand out in the block.

So let’s delve deeper and explore the pros and cons of the two most popular roofing materials in the US.

1. Sturdiness and Material Quality

Durability and material differences are quite significant between metal and asphalt roofing. The former can be manufactured using different metals and alloys, whereas asphalt is a mixture of fiberglass, sand, and gavel. Metal roofs are considerably stronger and more durable than asphalt due to their bonded form and flat seam texture.

On the contrary, asphalt roofs are more susceptible to wind, fire, and water damage.

2. Weight and Resistance

Many homeowners think metal roofs are heavier than asphalt and concrete roofing, but it’s untrue. In contrast, metal roofs are considered the most lightweight roofing product in the market. Unlike asphalt roofs, it’s not manufactured in multiple pieces, making it easier to install, clean, and maintain.

The design and heaviness of asphalt roofs offer more room for insects and moisture. They can also shrink due to heat and fail to protect a property from UV rays and strong wind.

3. Durability and Efficiency

Roofing contractors in NC installing a new metal roof

We love the recyclability of metal roofs and their high energy efficiency. Metal roofs can protect your home from intense heat and cold and ensure maximum energy conservation. They’re undoubtedly the more sustainable choice for eco-conscious homeowners and can last for 50 years or more.

On the flip side, asphalt roofs are neither efficient nor durable. They tend to absorb a lot of heat that can cause shingle loss and breakage.

We can conclude that metal roofs are a better and safer option for homeowners due to their excellent durability, performance, energy efficiency, and aesthetic appeal.

Hire Gator Home Professionals for Premium Quality Galvalume Metal Roofs in North Carolina

At Gator Home Professionals, we offer the best-quality metal roofing services, repair, maintenance, and inspection across North Carolina. Our metal roofs are made with high-grade materials and can make your property stand out in the neighborhood!

Call us today for more details, request an in-home consultation via our website, or get a free quote now

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Articles to explore
Divider with a gator
Photo of a mobile home with a gray sanding seam metal roof.

Upgrade Your Mobile Home to a Gator Home Professionals Roof

Welcome to Gator Home Professionals, your experts in Mobile Home Metal Roofing! As a homeowner in North Carolina, we want to explore why metal roofing is a superior choice for mobile homes compared to shingles. With its durability, energy efficiency, and long-term cost savings, metal roofing is an excellent investment for mobile homes in the Carolinas. The southeast is known for its unpredictable weather patterns, including heavy rain, high winds, and even occasional hailstorms. Metal roofing provides exceptional protection against these elements, making it an ideal choice for trailers. Unlike shingles, which can be easily damaged or blown off, metal roofs offer superior resistance, ensuring your trailer

He Won a FREE Roof—You Can Too!

Every year, Gator Home Professionals—formerly Gator Metal Roofing—selects a random winner from our Sweepstakes to receive a FREE metal roof replacement! This year our winner is in Blacksburg, South Carolina, Jason receives a large check and a brand new metal roof as seen on our YouTube channel. Our 2025 Sweepstakes Winner & His New Metal Roof Our team of professionals venture to Blacksburg, SC to install and document Jason’s big win and same-day installation. Watch as his hurricane damaged shingles are replaced with a sleek black metal roof! Video Transcript Chapter 1: Surprise Giveaway Announcement Nichole: Hey everyone, I’m Nichole with Gator Metal Roofing and we are

Carolina home with the Elite Series Standing Seam Metal Roof in Hawaiian Blue.

Gator Home Professionals Launches Elite Series Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Delivering Unmatched Durability and Curb Appeal to Carolina Homeowners GARNER, NC – April 8, 2026 – Gator Home Professionals, a trusted leader in residential metal roofing and window replacement, today announced the official rollout of its new Elite Series Standing Seam Metal Roofing system. Designed to withstand the most extreme weather known to North Carolina and South Carolina while elevating modern home aesthetics, the Elite Series sets a new standard for premium metal roofing in the region. Unlike traditional corrugated metal or asphalt shingle roofs, the Elite Series features a concealed fastener system with raised interlocking seams. This engineering eliminates exposed screw penetrations—the primary source of leaks

Spring Savings Event: Get $3,000 off a NEW metal roof & buy 3 windows, get 1 FREE!