Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles

Side by side of asphalt shingles vs metal roofing.

Roofing technology and techniques have seen drastic improvements in recent times – and metal roofing has quickly risen to become the clear choice for roofing thanks to its incredible durability and longevity.

If you’ve spent any time looking into installing a new roof, you’ve likely been floored by the sheer amount of different options available to you. When deciding between Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles, there are many things to consider. Shingles are undoubtedly the most popular roofing material today because they are easy to maintain, cost-effective, weather-resistant, and reliable. Continue reading to learn all about metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles.

The History of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are originally an American invention, first used in 1901. They can attribute a lot of their popularity to a movement by the US National Board of Fire Underwriters to stop using wood shingles on roofs in the 1920s, which was very successful.

At first, almost all shingles were organic. Cotton rag was commonly used as the base material until the 1920’s when economic and wartime stresses caused the prices of cotton rag to increase, prompting manufacturers to seek cheaper alternatives.

Eventually, manufacturers landed on asphalt – the perfect temporary roofing material.  It is incredibly cheap for them to mass produce, and it needs to be fully replaced at least 3 times in every home’s life cycle, designed to be a temporary solution. Perfect for the roofer that wants to guarantee himself a lifelong customer, whether you like it or not!

Metal is Everything Shingles Wish They Were

All our metal roofing, called substrate, is made from Galvalume, a German technology, that emulates galvanized steel and is coated with a mixture of zinc and aluminum and siliconized coating to protect against corrosion and rust.

More About Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles

Galvalume metal is perfect for accents on your office building, rustic and modern style homes, and even stores and restaurants. The Galvalume metal itself has more of a matte finish and it just has a bit more subtlety than the traditional shiny metal roof panels.

Metal roofs made with Galvalume metal are coated with a unique mixture of zinc, aluminum, and silicon coating to help resist scuffs, scratches, and anything that may hurt your metal roof! This incredible mixture helps the Galvalume metal resist rust and corrosion much better than traditional galvanized steel, giving it a longer lifespan on average.

It costs far less to maintain your metal roofing as well. If you want something like asphalt shingles to last forever, you will need constant maintenance and upkeep. Wind will cause some shingles to flap up over time, and water will eventually seep into any place it can. A metal roof is nearly wholly maintenance-free; the only thing you may have to do from time to time is spray it off if it ever gets dirty!

The Army Corps of Engineers did studies that found a properly installed metal roof can last for up to 100 years, while asphalt tends to hit its limit at about 20 years, give or take.

Sustainability and recyclability of Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles

One fantastic upside of choosing a metal roof is that almost every piece can be recycled again and again after it’s served its lifespan as a roof, making them a far more sustainable choice than asphalt shingles. The ability to reflect heat and sunlight makes metal roofs a far more energy-efficient roof as they block the majority of the outside heat from transmitting anywhere close to your home. The clear winner in the metal roofing vs asphalt shingles is metal roofing.

Asphalt shingles also have a drastically shorter lifespan than metal roofing. Consequently of that American landfills receive on average 20 billion pounds of old asphalt shingles every year. To make matters worse, asphalt shingles are petroleum-based, further increasing dependency on fossil fuels and polluting landfills.

👉 Call us today for your free estimate.

👉 Check out our Facebook page for metal roofing success stories!

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Articles to explore

Divider with a gator
Photo of a mobile home with a gray sanding seam metal roof.

Upgrade Your Mobile Home to a Gator Home Professionals Roof

Welcome to Gator Home Professionals, your experts in Mobile Home Metal Roofing! As a homeowner in North Carolina, we want to explore why metal roofing is a superior choice for mobile homes compared to shingles. With its durability, energy efficiency, and long-term cost savings, metal roofing is an excellent investment for mobile homes in the Carolinas. The southeast is known for its unpredictable weather patterns, including heavy rain, high winds, and even occasional hailstorms. Metal roofing provides exceptional protection against these elements, making it an ideal choice for trailers. Unlike shingles, which can be easily damaged or blown off, metal roofs offer superior resistance, ensuring your trailer

He Won a FREE Roof—You Can Too!

Every year, Gator Home Professionals—formerly Gator Metal Roofing—selects a random winner from our Sweepstakes to receive a FREE metal roof replacement! This year our winner is in Blacksburg, South Carolina, Jason receives a large check and a brand new metal roof as seen on our YouTube channel. Our 2025 Sweepstakes Winner & His New Metal Roof Our team of professionals venture to Blacksburg, SC to install and document Jason’s big win and same-day installation. Watch as his hurricane damaged shingles are replaced with a sleek black metal roof! Video Transcript Chapter 1: Surprise Giveaway Announcement Nichole: Hey everyone, I’m Nichole with Gator Metal Roofing and we are

Carolina home with the Elite Series Standing Seam Metal Roof in Hawaiian Blue.

Gator Home Professionals Launches Elite Series Standing Seam Metal Roofing

Delivering Unmatched Durability and Curb Appeal to Carolina Homeowners GARNER, NC – April 8, 2026 – Gator Home Professionals, a trusted leader in residential metal roofing and window replacement, today announced the official rollout of its new Elite Series Standing Seam Metal Roofing system. Designed to withstand the most extreme weather known to North Carolina and South Carolina while elevating modern home aesthetics, the Elite Series sets a new standard for premium metal roofing in the region. Unlike traditional corrugated metal or asphalt shingle roofs, the Elite Series features a concealed fastener system with raised interlocking seams. This engineering eliminates exposed screw penetrations—the primary source of leaks

Spring Savings Event: Get $3,000 off a NEW metal roof & buy 3 windows, get 1 FREE!